Apple Sued Over Facetime in Lethal Texas Car Crash From 2014

Kari ReynoldsJan 04, 2017

A couple in Texas, whose five-year-old daughter was killed in a vehicle accident after a distracted driver on FaceTime slammed into their auto, is suing Apple.

The driver, "distracted while using the "FaceTime" application on an iPhone 6 Plus during the operation of his motor vehicle", crashed at 65 miles per hour into the back of a vehicle that was stationary due to traffic, the court documents say.

The tragic incident occurred on December 24, 2014 near Dallas, Texas when the Modisette family was traveling in their Toyota Camry.

"Apple, Inc.'s failure to exercise reasonable care caused or contributed to the risk of causing Garrett Wilhelm to use "FaceTime" while driving his vehicle ... which caused him to be distracted from the conditions on the road ahead", according to the lawsuit.

"Despite the fact that Apple Inc. has had the technology since at least 2008 to implement a 'lock-out mechanism without requiring any modifications or additions to a vehicle by using a motion analyzer, a scenery analyzer and a lock-out mechanism, ' Apple Inc. has never implemented its technology on any of its iPhones".

It points to a patent for a such feature for drivers filed by Apple in 2008.


The lawsuit states that as a result of the distraction caused by FaceTime the SUV driver struck the Modisette family at full highway speed from the behind, which had caused their Camry to propel forward, rotate and come to a final rest at an angle facing the wrong direction in the right lane of traffic. The vehicle behind them, a Toyota 4Runner driven by Garrett Wilhelm, unfortunately failed to stop and slammed into the rear of the Modisette family's auto, severely injuring all members of the family and killing five-year-old Moriah in the process.

Police say he admitted to using FaceTime at the time of the crash and had the application open on his phone when they arrived at the scene. But Apple's failures "were a substantial factor in causing the plaintiffs' injuries and decedent's death", the lawsuit states.

Wilhelm was indicted on manslaughter charges by Denton County, Texas, according to the Denton Record-Chronicles.

"At the time of the collision in question, the iPhone utilized by Wilhelm contained the necessary hardware (to be configured with software) to automatically disable or "lock-out" the ability to use [FaceTime]".

Filed in California Superior Court in Santa Clara County late last month, the suit also claims that Apple failed "to warn users that the product was likely to be unsafe when used or misused". Despite admitting to using the phone, Wilhelm's lawyer, Ricky Perritt, does not feel the device contributed to the crash.

Related Articles:



« Previous article
Next article »


Popular Pages

Greek Ambassador to Brazil Missing for Three Days
Crime in Rio has been rising and the state is deeply indebted, often unable to pay police and other salaries on time if at all. The ambassador's charred rental auto could be seen in the parking lot outside the police station, an AFP correspondent said.

Facebook & Google dominate the list of 2016's top apps
The social networking app had more than 146 million average unique users each month, a growth of 14 percent from previous year . In third-quarter, a majority of subscribers used Android (53 percent) and iOS (45 percent) devices to access their apps.

Adele & Longtime Boyfriend Finally Married? Check Out The Ring She's Wearing
Adele allegedly marries Simon Konecki in a private ceremony. "The plan is to marry in L.A. In March, the singer sported a gold band on her ring finger during one of her concerts.

Ed Sheeran's New Music Album To Be Titled 'Divide'!
Are you excited? Share your thoughts in the comment section below. Sheeran's last studio album X was released in June 2014. Sorry, this content isn't available on your device.

Harden's Triple-Double Leads Win Over Shorthanded Clippers
Trey Burke came off the bench to score 20 of his season-high 27 points in the first half of Washington's 118-95 rout of Brooklyn. Keyed by a pair of three-pointers by Marreese Speights, the Clippers fought back with an 18-4 run that cut the deficit to 64-53.

Park Visitors Spend Nearly 8 Hours Trapped on Ride
There was not an immediate reason given by Knott's Berry Farm for the reason why the Sky Cabin ride broke down. The passengers, as a sort of recompense for the ride's malfunction, were given free passes to the park.

FCA to reveal self-driving, electric concept vehicle at CES
However, that doesn't seem to have dissuaded Chrysler from packing in as much technology into the Portal Concept as it could. The Chrysler Portal is merely a concept, and it's not expected to receive the green light for production any time soon.

Trump says United States will buy, hire American
Later Tuesday, Trump thanked himself for a surge in a key gauge of consumer confidence. In 2013, he terribly tweeted about "winners" and "losers" on the anniversary of 9/11.

FOX News' Megyn Kelly jumps ship to NBC
But she is clearly a leading voice for right-wing viewpoints, which is why Fox reportedly offered her $20 million a year to stay. When she shared her own account of Ailes treating female Fox News Staffers inappropriately, many believe Ailes' fate was sealed.

Dude runs on stage and steals World Darts Trophy during competition
MVG subsequently lost momentum with Anderson taking advantage bt he got back on track to take the win. The night ended with that total at 708, with Anderson hitting 22 in the game and Van Gerwen 20.